No census data, no measuring stick, no justice: What’s at stake in the 2030 Census

Meeta Anand is senior director of census and data equity at the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights. Terry Ao Minnis is vice president of census and voting programs at Asian Americans Advancing Justice | AAJC. Arturo Vargas is the former CEO of the National Association of Latino Elected and Appointed Officials and its affiliate, the NALEO Educational Fund.

The recent proposal to remove race and ethnicity questions from the 2030 Census has caused a stir among policy advocates, public health professionals, and legal experts who warn that such a move could prove disastrous. Though the proposal has largely flown under the public’s radar, it’s a clear attempt to “whitewash” our country and ignore the needs of communities of color. Supporters of this dangerous proposal say the Constitution requires only a head count, but we know that removing these questions would weaken civil rights enforcement and the tracking of disparities in health, education, housing, jobs, and representation. Disparities that aren’t measured can’t be addressed.

Race and ethnicity data have helped the U.S. government make critical decisions about how to serve the public since the first census was conducted in 1790.

Eliminating race and ethnicity data collection is unprecedented, violates civil rights statutes, and would have widespread, devastating consequences. Those consequences may not be immediate, but they would be felt for generations, because surveys and data sets across government and the private sector depend on census race and ethnicity data. Without that foundation, reliable information on the nation’s racial and ethnic makeup would effectively disappear. Race and ethnicity data are essential for (1) understanding population diversity, ensuring fair and equitable treatment, and making informed decisions that help all communities; (2) helping government agencies design, implement, and fund programs that target specific populations in areas such as housing, education, health care, and transportation; (3) evaluating policy impacts; and (4) identifying disparities in access to services, economic opportunities, and health outcomes to guide targeted solutions.

Federal civil rights laws depend on race and ethnicity data for effective enforcement. While many of these laws don’t explicitly require collecting the data, the protections can’t be enforced without accurate and reflective data.

So how exactly might this proposal to remove race and ethnicity questions from the 2030 Census affect you or people you know? Let’s take a look.

Many of us quickly fill out the census once a decade and don’t give it another thought. But those race and ethnicity questions quietly power many of the protections we count on every day. Here’s where they show up.

Housing: Where you get to live

Picture this: Michelle and her partner have respectable credit scores, steady jobs, and a down payment saved. But every time they ask about homes in their dream neighborhood, their agent steers them somewhere else. And their mortgage applications keep getting denied while friends with similar finances pass through without a hiccup.

The Fair Housing Act of 1968 makes it illegal to discriminate against people renting, buying, or financing a home based on race, religion, disability, and other characteristics. But proving a pattern of discrimination takes a yardstick. Census data show who actually lives in a neighborhood or city. If a metro area is 30% Black but a lender almost never approves Black borrowers, investigators know where to dig. No census data, no measuring stick, no justice.

Education: Where your kids learn

Your school district announces new boundary zones. Officially, it’s about “efficiency” or “cost-saving measures,” but  the new lines seem to funnel kids from the same few neighborhoods into the oldest, most overcrowded building in town.

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 bars schools that receive federal money — which means nearly every public school — from discriminating based on race, color, or national origin. Ever since Brown v. Board of Education, race and ethnicity data have been how we check whether equal access is actually happening. Census data show who lives where, so families and civil rights officials can see whether new boundaries are sorting kids equitably. Federal education law also requires education statistics broken down by race and ethnicity, and regulators rely on those data to evaluate how federally funded programs serve different groups of students.

Federally funded programs: Your bus route, your library, your food and nutrition programs

Your city’s transit agency is cutting bus routes to save money. The routes on the chopping block mostly serve Black and Brown neighborhoods, where many riders depend on the bus to get to work.

Title VI covers any program that takes federal dollars, including transit, social services, and parks. Agencies have to prove they aren’t discriminating, which means comparing the people their programs serve with the communities around them. Transit agencies that receive federal funds, for example, generally must run an equity analysis before major service cuts. That analysis is built on census demographics. Without it, nobody can tell who is bearing the brunt.

Health care: Your family’s health

Your aunt mentions that many women in her community seem to be having serious complications during pregnancy. Is it bad luck, or is something bigger going on?

To answer that, public health experts need a rate, and every rate needs two numbers: how many people are affected and how many people are in the group overall. That second number comes from the census. Without it, you can count cases, but you can’t tell whether one community is being hit harder than another. Those numbers are how we know about disparities in maternal mortality, diabetes, asthma, and cancer, and how we decide where to send resources.

Title VI also covers hospitals and health programs that get federal funding. On top of that, federal law specifically requires health data broken down by race and ethnicity, including Census Bureau data on uninsured kids by family income, age, and race or ethnicity.

Voting rights: Your voice at the polls

Your grandfather became a citizen years ago and hasn’t missed an election since. He reads Vietnamese far more comfortably than English. Under the Voting Rights Act, he can get a ballot and voting materials in his language, but only in places where census data show enough voters need that help.

Employment: Your job and your paycheck

Jordan is a qualified electrician applying to a big local contractor. Electricians in the area come from all backgrounds, but the company’s crews are almost entirely white, and applicants of color keep hearing “we went another direction.”

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act makes workplace discrimination illegal. To spot patterns, investigators compare a company’s workforce with the local labor market: who actually works in that field in that area and what they earn. That benchmark comes from census race and ethnicity data combined with occupation and earnings data. Without it, an employer’s claim that its workforce matches the local talent pool can’t be checked.

Everyone’s stake: Why this isn’t just about some of us

The bottom line: These questions aren’t “immaterial.” They’re the measuring stick that makes civil rights laws enforceable. Take away the measuring stick and the laws stay on the books, but proving anyone broke them gets much harder.

Dropping the questions wouldn’t erase disparities or discrimination. It would only make them harder to measure and fix. Accurate data make public spending more efficient, while worse data lead to misdirected resources and missed gaps. Because communities are interconnected, barriers facing some groups cost everyone through slower growth, higher public costs, and lost potential. Imperfect measurement should be met with better measurement, not none.

What to do now

Time is short, but there are three things you can do before the November 2 deadline:

  1. Submit a public comment telling the Census Bureau how the proposed changes could affect your community, and urge the bureau not to adopt them.
  2. Call for more time to respond. Submit or sign on to a letter asking the Census Bureau to extend the public comment period through December 10.
  3. Spread the word. Share the proposed changes, comment deadline, and available resources with your networks and encourage others to submit comments.